Disability Wales responds to the Milburn Report on Young People and Work

Disability Wales logo which has the organisation name in English and Welsh in plain text on a white background. The words are framed on the left hand side by four spirals in DW's trademark blue and orange colours.

The Milburn Review rightly acknowledges the failure of successive governments to tackle the multiple barriers faced by young people in the education and employment system, however its proposals to address these not only fall wide of the mark but are damaging and divisive and risk condemning another generation of young disabled people to a lifetime of poverty and exclusion.

Far from being an investment in youth opportunity, it is a thinly veiled attempt to cut £3.6 billion a year from disability and incapacity benefits, creating a two tier system by abolishing Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and the Universal Credit health element (LCWRA) for the under-25s. Moreover we are very concerned that it will lead to a punitive system of sanctions for young disabled people perceived as disengaging from the process, creating a life-threatening cliff-edge where they could be left with no financial means to survive. 

Furthermore, given that under-25s represent just 13% of working-age disability claimants, the report makes ominous calls on the UK Government to roll out this same model to over-25s.

In Wales, over one in five people are disabled, and we face Britain’s highest Disability Employment Gap at 31.2%. However it appears that young disabled people in Wales could be hardest hit by these very proposals. The data indicates that 45% of young people not in education, employment or training are disabled, yet its economic modelling fails to account for labour market displacement. In Wales, where there are roughly two unemployed jobseekers for every open vacancy, therefore paying employers to take on young people specifically may displace older age groups out of employment. The statistical analysis neither calculates nor accounts for this displacement. We have serious concerns that these plans may just move the problems around and make it harder for older adults to secure opportunities.

Furthermore, Millburn assumes that the extra employment opportunities will be created mostly in front-facing retail and hospitality roles; which risks pigeonholing individuals into set occupations, whilst not allowing the right of choice or the opportunity to flourish in jobs which may be better suited to their interests and personal circumstances. Disabled young people are not a lost generation as suggested in the report; many are unique, skilled creative individuals who have many skills for which opportunities do not exist for these to be utilised. When a large proportion of these people will be neurodivergent young people with sensory issues, pushing them into inaccessible, high-stress retail environments sets them up to fail. Real opportunity requires investment in true job carving, ongoing post-25 support and accessible remote, digital, tech, and creative pathways that remove sensory and rural transport barriers.

Millburn acknowledges that his ‘diagnosis is UK-wide, but the institutional answer will differ because education, skills, health and local government are devolved in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland’. While UK Government will have the power to impose cuts in benefits to disabled people in Wales, it is unclear whether any consequential funding to Welsh Government will be sufficient to devise the bespoke solutions required to address the higher level of need in Wales.  

DW’s Chief Executive, Rhian Davies said:

“We are working hard in Wales to implement the ten-year Disabled People’s Rights Plan (2025–2035)which takes a coproduced, cross cutting approach to tackling the range of barriers faced by disabled people in education, employment, transport, housing and social care. Meanwhile top-down Westminster welfare proposals continue to undermine our progress and further underlines DW’s 2026 Manifesto Call for devolution of benefits to Wales. We call on Welsh Government to respond robustly to the Milburn Report and speak against its damaging proposals and scapegoating of disabled people. Moreover to continue to work coproductively with disabled people in Wales to create a society that is genuinely inclusive, equitable and barrier free”.

Become a member today and become part of what we do

Members